- In 1990, an individual dressed as a clown knocked on Marlene Warren’s door and shot her within the head earlier than escaping in a white Chrysler LeBaron.
- In 2017, Shelia Eager-Warren was charged with the homicide of Marlene Warren, however her protection staff say the proof will not be robust sufficient to help her being held in jail with out bail for greater than three years.
- His attorneys say that three of the 4 witnesses to the crime advised investigators the clown was a minimum of six ft tall and was male, however that Eager-Warren is 5 ft tall and is feminine.
- Visit the Insider homepage for more stories.
A Florida lady accused of disguising herself as a clown in a murder 27-year-old chilly case has been jailed with out bail since 2017.
In a bail utility filed Jan. 4, her attorneys are attempting to get her launched earlier than trial.
In 2017, Sheila Eager-Warren was charged with the 1990 homicide of her husband’s spouse, Marlene Warren.
In Might 1990, an individual in a clown costume driving a white Chrysler LeBaron drove to the house of Michael and Marlene Warren in Wellington, Florida, in response to the info and procedural historical past part of the bail petition. by Eager-Warren.
The clown knocked on the entrance door of the home, carrying two balloons and a flower association. After Marlene Warren answered the door, the clown shot her within the head earlier than strolling in direction of the Lebaron and leaving the premises.
“There isn’t any dependable bodily or testimonial proof that she dedicated this crime, but Ms. Eager-Warren has been in jail with out bail since October 4, 2017,” Eager-Warren’s attorneys submitted to court docket. “Any continued restriction on his freedom is each punitive and a violation of the presumption of innocence.”
The taking pictures was investigated by 4 totally different teams of detectives, nevertheless it wasn’t till Detective Paige McCann took over the case in 2013 that the state had possible causes to accuse Eager-Warren. of Marlene Warren’s homicide, in response to the protection staff.
However within the 4 years that McCann investigated the case, the one further proof uncovered was microscopic hair and an FBI scan, in response to protection paperwork.
Protection argues proof towards their shopper is scarce and she or he ought to a minimum of be launched earlier than trial
Legal professionals for Eager-Warren mentioned proof offered by the state to incarcerate their shopper was scarce and unreliable.
“After a 27-year investigation that discovered no credible proof linking Sheila Eager-Warren to the homicide of Marlene Warren,” Eager-Warren’s attorneys wrote, “the state has decided it has ample proof to prosecute her on the idea of fragile circumstantial proof. on fragile circumstantial proof. “
4 individuals witnessed the taking pictures: Warren’s son Joseph and his three associates.
Instantly after the incident, his attorneys mentioned, three of the witnesses advised investigators “unequivocally” that the clown was a tall man measuring 6 to six ft 2 inches – the fourth witness couldn’t inform if the clown was male or not, however confirmed the scale of the killer.
In line with the protection, one of many witnesses additionally advised investigators that “it was a person, it was not a lady”.
However Eager-Warren is a 5-foot-7-inch lady.
Prosecutors mentioned of their movement to confess proof that witnesses described the killer as having “manly options.”
State prosecutors additionally mentioned in court docket paperwork that on the time of the homicide, Eager-Warren was a “taller, slender white lady with lengthy brown hair and masculine options.”
Of their movement, the protection staff continued to checklist the the explanation why the proof supplied by the state will not be ample to carry their shopper with out bond.
After the taking pictures, investigators went to Publix, a grocery retailer, and spoke to 2 staff who mentioned a lady purchased balloons and flowers just like the flowers discovered on the scene. When Eager-Warren’s photograph was positioned in a photograph checklist for workers to browse, they could not establish Eager-Warren as the client, his attorneys mentioned.
Two staff of a dressing up retailer additionally contacted investigators and mentioned they bought a clown costume to a lady simply two days earlier than the murder, court docket paperwork present. After being offered with a spread of images together with Eager-Warren, not one of the staff might definitively title Eager-Warren as the client, the protection mentioned.
In line with the protection staff, it was solely a yr after the murder that staff have been questioned a second and third time earlier than admitting to discussing the case collectively and studying newspaper articles with the photograph by Eager-Warren.
Because of this, in response to the protection staff, the 2 staff “immediately expressed extra confidence of their identifications.”
Throughout their search, investigators recovered a number of white Chrysler LeBarons that they believed may very well be the getaway automotive, one in every of which was linked to a grand theft dedicated 30 days earlier than the taking pictures and had ties to Michael Warren.
In line with the protection, the Palm Seashore County Sheriff’s Workplace recovered a number of fibers and hairs from the car, however a criminal offense witness has repeatedly denied that the car was the getaway automotive in query. After forensic proof, the FBI found that DNA from the pores and skin on the root of a hair discovered within the automotive was primarily from a person, the protection mentioned.
Lastly, the protection claims that the state discovered orange / yellow acrylic hair within the car and that the FBI solely analyzed “yellow modacrylic wig-type fibers.” In line with the protection file, after interviewing the three witnesses who described the clown as sporting a wig, none of them mentioned the wig was yellow – two witnesses mentioned it was crimson and one mentioned it was crimson. mentioned it was orange.
Sheila Eager-Warren and Michael Warren tied the knot in 2002
When questioned by investigators, Eager-Warren denied any romantic involvement between her and Michael Warren on the time of the homicide. The 2 owned a restaurant in Tennessee, The Purple Cow, from 1993 to 2016, in response to court docket paperwork.
Twelve years after the murder, the 2 obtained married. In line with WJHL, the couple have been dwelling in Abingdon, Va., when Eager-Warren was extradited to Florida in 2017.
In line with Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure, all offenders, besides these charged with an offense punishable by capital punishment or an offense punishable by life imprisonment, have “the best to provisional launch on cheap phrases”. As Eager-Warren is charged with manslaughter, she will not be instantly eligible for interim launch.
In mild of this, and because of the preponderance of conflicting proof and the rising risk of COVID-19 within the US jail system, Eager-Warren’s attorneys have requested the court docket of their movement to set $ 50,000 bail. for Eager-Warren to be positioned in Dwelling Arrest from the Palm Seashore Sheriff’s Workplace if the court docket requires extra restrictive circumstances for his launch.
The prosecution staff declined to remark, noting that they might “not make extrajudicial feedback on an open case.”